What Is “Lawsuit Abuse,” and Why Should You Care?
Picture your car insurance renewal showing up with a number that makes you do a double take. Your agent mentions “the legal environment” and moves on. That vague answer is the tip of a bigger iceberg that impacts millions of people across the state. Lawsuit abuse is, in short, what happens when lawsuits, jury payouts, and outside money flowing into legal cases grow far faster than Alabama’s economy can handle. None of it stays in the courtroom. It leaks into your insurance bill, your doctor’s office, and everyday prices.
A bill rising faster than everything else
Between 2020 and 2024, Alabama’s liability claims got 59% more expensive, while everyday prices rose just 23%. It’s not that more Alabamians are suing; claim counts have stayed roughly flat. What’s changed is the price tag on each one. The average payout per claim jumped 45%, to $5,087, and claims over $1 million have doubled since 2020. Lawsuit-related claims are fewer than 1 in 10 of all claims filed here, yet consume more than a third of everything insurers pay out.
Nationally, “nuclear verdicts” over $10 million jumped 52% in 2024, totaling $31.3 billion. Alabama has its own entries in that ledger, including a 2023 state Supreme Court–upheld $10 million malpractice verdict. There’s also a newer wrinkle: outside investment firms now fund lawsuits they have no stake in, just to collect a cut later. ALR estimates this “litigation funding” adds more than $600 a year to what the average Alabamian pays.
Follow the money and it lands somewhere ordinary: the small business that can’t afford to hire because of rising premiums, the rural hospital (74% already operate at a loss) absorbing malpractice costs on top of that strain, and your own household budget, paying quietly into a system pricing in the risk of unpredictable verdicts.
Why ALR exists
Alabamians for Legal Reform was formed because this problem was growing largely unnoticed. Alabama hasn’t meaningfully modernized its legal system in about 30 years, even as neighboring states acted. ALR exists to close that gap: researching what’s driving these costs, translating it into plain language, and building a coalition of families, small business owners, healthcare providers, and local leaders who can push lawmakers toward fair, predictable reform.
“We cannot afford to remain on a path of increased unaffordability, limited growth.” — State Sen. Josh Carnley
That’s the choice in front of Alabama: keep absorbing a quiet tax embedded in every premium, or work to fix a system that is quickly bending under its own weight.
← Back to Blog Posts